Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: What does NSF think of bonuses for grantmanship?
Robert Campbell

Date:
What does NSF think of bonuses for grantmanship?
Permalink Closed


What do granting agencies, such as the National Science Foundation, think about bonuses to faculty members who get grants with buyout provisions?

I've been told of a case in which NSF is going after UCal San Diego for operating a program somewhat like MIDAS.

The complaint is supposedly that paying a faculty member a bonus for getting a grant amounts to increasing the compensation that the professor is getting paid from the grant beyond the amount that was agreed upon.

Any further information about this issue would be most helpful.

Robert Campbell

__________________
stinky cheese man

Date:
Permalink Closed

i don't know for a fact, but most of the grants here aren't funded by NSF.

__________________
Otherside

Date:
RE: RE: What does NSF think of bonuses for grantma
Permalink Closed


quote:
Originally posted by: stinky cheese man

"i don't know for a fact, but most of the grants here aren't funded by NSF. "


Stinky is correct. NSF only pays summer salary and usually requires a match from the university. It sounds like the other school was sending "overhead" money back to the prof. That isn't allowed.

This is true for most gov. grants and that is why it's so hard to get the bonus money. I hear that some of the "grants" are really "pork" in that our senators in D.C. direct the Army , etc to fund certain projects.

If faculty want to do this it's OK with me, but why not just take a job in industry. You can do it full time with no teaching. Why work for a Univ. then buy out your teaching time?????

__________________
Robert Campbell

Date:
RE: What does NSF think of bonuses for grantmanshi
Permalink Closed


I have confirmation that NSF is going after UCSD, but no details on the case.

But I do know that any ruling that bonuses for grantsmanship are contrary to Federal regulations will apply to any Federal granting agency, not just NSF.

Robert Campbell

__________________
Googler

Date:
RE: RE: RE: What does NSF think of bonuses for grantma
Permalink Closed


quote:

Originally posted by: Otherside

"If faculty want to do this it's OK with me, but why not just take a job in industry. You can do it full time with no teaching. Why work for a Univ. then buy out your teaching time?????"

Will these MIDAS checks bump up the recipient's future retirement benefits from the state of Mississippi? (The retirement benefits are based on a average of the four highest earning years.)

__________________
truth4usm/AH

Date:
RE: RE: RE: What does NSF think of bonuses for grantmanship?
Permalink Closed


quote:

Originally posted by: stinky cheese man

"i don't know for a fact, but most of the grants here aren't funded by NSF. "


What do you mean???  The two largest grants USM has received in recent years came from NSF.  I know because I wrote one of them!


Maybe in terms of quantity, most grants aren't funded by NSF, but there is plenty of grant $$ from the NSF at USM.


Please explain your comment!




__________________
truth4usm/AH

Date:
Permalink Closed

quote:

Originally posted by: stinky cheese man

"i don't know for a fact, but most of the grants here aren't funded by NSF. "


What do you mean???  The two largest grants USM has received in recent years came from NSF.  I know because I wrote one of them!


Maybe in terms of quantity, most grants aren't funded by NSF, but there is plenty of grant $$ from the NSF at USM.


Please explain your comment!




__________________
truth4usm/AH

Date:
Permalink Closed

quote:

Originally posted by: truth4usm/AH

" What do you mean???  The two largest grants USM has received in recent years came from NSF.  I know because I wrote one of them! Maybe in terms of quantity, most grants aren't funded by NSF, but there is plenty of grant $$ from the NSF at USM. Please explain your comment! "

Sorry, as you can tell I was REALLY confused! 

__________________
truth4usm/AH

Date:
RE: RE: RE: What does NSF think of bonuses for grantma
Permalink Closed


quote:

Originally posted by: Otherside

"  If faculty want to do this it's OK with me, but why not just take a job in industry. You can do it full time with no teaching. Why work for a Univ. then buy out your teaching time?????"

<SARCASM> Because they wouldn't be able to be "lazy and unproductive" in industry. </SARCASM>

__________________
LeavingASAP

Date:
RE: RE: RE: RE: What does NSF think of bonuses for
Permalink Closed


quote:
Originally posted by: truth4usm/AH

"<SARCASM> Because they wouldn't be able to be "lazy and unproductive" in industry. </SARCASM>"


Ah Ha!! Truth4USM is Roy Klumb!!!




__________________
stinky cheese man

Date:
RE: What does NSF think of bonuses for grantmanship?
Permalink Closed


as i said, i could be wrong.  i have heard any number of COST faculty note that much of the grant money in the college is really "pork-barrel (sp?)."  by that i mean that it's not as competitive as going through channels like NSF; it often relies on connections with Lott or Cochran.  in fact, polymer science hired someone recently (i don't remember who) that had the perceived ability to get NSF money. 

__________________
truth4usm/AH

Date:
RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: What does NSF think of bonuses for
Permalink Closed


quote:

Originally posted by: LeavingASAP

" Ah Ha!! Truth4USM is Roy Klumb!!! "

Darn, you've outed me!  No, really, Roy and I do share the same brain...the only problem is I have it 99% of the time! 

__________________
truth4usm/AH

Date:
RE: RE: What does NSF think of bonuses for grantmanship?
Permalink Closed


quote:

Originally posted by: stinky cheese man

"as i said, i could be wrong.  i have heard any number of COST faculty note that much of the grant money in the college is really "pork-barrel (sp?)."  by that i mean that it's not as competitive as going through channels like NSF; it often relies on connections with Lott or Cochran.  in fact, polymer science hired someone recently (i don't remember who) that had the perceived ability to get NSF money.  "

Yep, "pork" (or "congressional marks," as they like to call it when they "pretty it up") does come to USM, as it does to many other universities.  The Polymer Palace was originally built with pork from the USDA (and connections to Cochran).  It's not competitive at all; it's about who you know and what sort of project you're proposing (i.e. can the congressperson get it through the federal budget process).  It is "funnelled" through various federal agencies, and it is the best kind of $$ since it has no (or virtually no) strings attached as grant or contract $$ does.  But since it doesn't buy out teaching loads, per se, does it count towards MIDAS?  Someone more in the know that me let us know about that.

__________________
Malapropism

Date:
RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: What does NSF think of bonuses for
Permalink Closed


quote:

Originally posted by: truth4usm/AH

"No, really, Roy and I do share the same brain...the only problem is I have it 99% of the time!  "

Yup, you just keep using 'em all up this week Truth...you'll have nothing left for future competitions...burn out, I feel it coming!

__________________
Otherside

Date:
RE: RE: RE: What does NSF think of bonuses for gra
Permalink Closed


quote:
Originally posted by: truth4usm/AH

"...But since it doesn't buy out teaching loads, per se, does it count towards MIDAS?  Someone more in the know that me let us know about that."


Yes Truth (...err Roy) they do buy out and does count towards MIDAS. For example, from the list in HA, Winstead,Whitehead and Leybourne I believe all work on "Eagle Eyes" a DOE project.

__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard