Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: "Discussion" on this Message Board
Debate Coach

Date:
"Discussion" on this Message Board
Permalink Closed


For all of the hubbub made about using logic, facts, and rational discussion on this message board, I frankly don't see much of it. I have read a number of posts recently that attacked this poster or that poster for not using factual information or logical deduction (or induction) when they were making their point(s).

It's pretty easy to say that sort of thing when you're able to make the rules and have a gang to back you up. I'd be willing to bet that none of you would last in a real debate contest where you have to argue a point of view that may not be aligned with your personal beliefs. That's true debate.

What you're doing here is a farce of such a high quality I've not seen in 20+ years of coaching debate at the university level. I'm glad one of my former students (who now teaches at USM) turned me on to this website; it's great when I need a good laugh.

__________________
Phish Phood

Date:
RE: "Discussion" on this Message Board
Permalink Closed


Bait thrown out. Do not bite.

__________________
Parallel universe

Date:
Permalink Closed

The quality debate faculty have already left USM or were fired tenured faculty members. We had some good debate teamers at USM, but they were recently kicked off the team for posting to this message board. Team rules, boards like this where intellectual street brawls can be found are off limits. These student-debaters could not resist, sadly Another controversy, we have a blue-chip debater joining us this year, but he has a sordid past, pulling a gun on an opponent in the US high school national debate chamionship after he thought he might lose. His defense was quite logical, might makes right, just look at how the government works. He actually ended up winning believe it or not, but the Ivy league schools saw him as tainted. So USM thought they could bring him to the Harvard of Hardy, not of Hattiesburg mind you, William Carey and Anotelli are fighting for this now. His arrival on campus is very controversial, but we expect a chamionship out of this fellow. Logic is for the weak. You only argue when you are weak.

__________________
Observer

Date:
Permalink Closed

Have you noticed that both "Doubting Thomas" and " Parallel Universe" use the word "Attacked" in place of the word "Rebutted"? I do believe the troll is back on at least 2 threads tonight. I'll let you guess which threads.

__________________
Third Witch

Date:
Permalink Closed

What tenured faculty were "fired"?? There was an attempt to fire G & S, but they were not actually fired.

__________________
Doubting Thomas

Date:
Permalink Closed


Observer wrote:

Have you noticed that both "Doubting Thomas" and " Parallel Universe" use the word "Attacked" in place of the word "Rebutted"? I do believe the troll is back on at least 2 threads tonight. I'll let you guess which threads.



You're really reaching, here. I am not "Parallel Universe".

__________________
Doubting Thomas

Date:
Permalink Closed


Observer wrote:

Have you noticed that both "Doubting Thomas" and " Parallel Universe" use the word "Attacked" in place of the word "Rebutted"? I do believe the troll is back on at least 2 threads tonight. I'll let you guess which threads.



The more I think about this stupid line of reasoning the more I realize that I can't let you get away with this nonsense. By your flawed logic, I am every poster who has used the work "attacked" when describing the manner in which I was treated by posters of your ilk. Shame on you for such sloppy reasoning.

Where is the general outcry when someone like "Observer" is besmirching my (pseudo) name with such shoddy reasoning?

__________________
Observer

Date:
Permalink Closed

Doubting Thomas wrote:


You're really reaching, here. I am not "Parallel Universe".

Well, you sure fooled me.    I wonder if "parallel universe" will agree.

__________________
Doubting Thomas

Date:
Permalink Closed


Observer wrote:

Doubting Thomas wrote:
You're really reaching, here. I am not "Parallel Universe".

Well, you sure fooled me.    I wonder if "parallel universe" will agree.




I don't know what he or she will say unless, of course, he or she is truthful.

Glad you chose to attack those who use similar verbage and not to dispute my post on "that other thread."

__________________
Invictus

Date:
Permalink Closed


Observer wrote:

Have you noticed that both "Doubting Thomas" and " Parallel Universe" use the word "Attacked" in place of the word "Rebutted"? I do believe the troll is back on at least 2 threads tonight. I'll let you guess which threads.



Both seem to have this place confused with a high school debate tournament, too. If they're not the same person, they're a tag team.

And now for a little musical interlude, courtesy of the Judds (Naomi, Wynonna & Stephen, no doubt!)


Workin' in the troll mine
Goin' on down, down
Workin' in a troll mine
Oops, about to slip down
Workin' in a troll mine
Goin' on down, down
Workin' in a troll mine
Oops, about to slip down


__________________
Johnny Fairplay

Date:
Permalink Closed

I thought that was a Devo song? Different generation?

__________________
Doubting Thomas

Date:
Permalink Closed


Johnny Fairplay wrote:

I thought that was a Devo song? Different generation?



"I refuse to exploit my opponent's youth and inexperience."

__________________
Invictus

Date:
Permalink Closed


Johnny Fairplay wrote:

I thought that was a Devo song? Different generation?



Lee Dorsey.

But then there's no "Stephen Dorsey" posting to this board, AFAIK.

__________________
Johnny Fairplay

Date:
RE: "Discussion" on this Message Board
Permalink Closed


Ah, then Devo covered it in the 80s. Disclaimer: admitting that I know this in no way makes me either youthful or inexperienced (unfortunately). But, could someone tell the old guy (DT) with the short fuse to knock it off?



__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard