Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: new IDV brochure
Amy Young

Date:
new IDV brochure
Permalink Closed


I found this brochure on the IDV website. It looks like 6 hours of graduate credit in two weeks!

http://www.usm.edu/idv/images/belize_bro.pdf

I am a bit disturbed by the description of Belize presented in the brochure as well. I would have thought that an international development program would have had quite different things to say about a developing country like Belize. As an anthropologist, I find it offensive. But free speech allows this sort of thing, of course.

I believe this is the sort of class that has gotten us into trouble with SACS probation. I have no firm evidence of this, but I have to wonder.

Amy Young




__________________
Googler

Date:
Permalink Closed

This program originates away from the home campus; therefore, it is considered distance learning. It probably would be wise not to initiate any new study abroad programs while on SACS probation due to concerns in the area of distance learning.


Here is a hot version of the link Amy referenced: http://www.usm.edu/idv/images/belize_bro.pdf


(Use the clockwise/counterclockwise function In Acrobat Reader to read the text.)



__________________
foot soldier

Date:
Permalink Closed

I too, find the description of Belize offensive (and badly written). What exactly is the discipline of this "course" (and I use the term only because I don't have another one)? What kind of "research?" Into what subject matter? You can't even tell what the "course" is about! It really does look like they're all just going to lie on the beach.

I happen to know a biology prof. who has a summer program in Belize for Ole Miss students. It is, in fact, a real course, though he sometimes encounters students who think they will get an automatic "A" just for going. They should sign up for this one.

__________________
Left (formerly Leaving Soon)

Date:
Permalink Closed

Would anyone care to contact the program's apparent director, david.butler@usm.edu, or USM's Center for International and Continuing Education, to find out more about this IDV 699 untitled course?

I agree with others -- the description of Belize is offensive, and the brochure is poorly written overall.

If this sort of thing is typical of distance learning USM-style, no wonder SACs has put USM on probation!

In the academic unit I left, the relentless push for online courses (another side of distance learning), in a discipline where such "content delivery" to our "customers" could hardly be effective, was of great concern to me and most of my colleagues. I still have to wonder, though -- is distance learning the only thing about USM that SACs is concerned about?

But hey, if I had given in to online teaching, I could still be drawing a salary from USM while living on the other side of the planet from Shelby Freland Thames. How very foolish of me to have resisted!

http://www.sparkimg.com/emoticons/bleh.gif



__________________
Defective Supercomputer

Date:
Permalink Closed

For some reason my supercomputer will not open he pdf. Would someone post two or three sentences of the Belize description?  Please.

__________________
Amy Young

Date:
Permalink Closed

This is not good. I googled and found...
If someone could make this a hotlink, you could read many of the words on the brochure.

http://webcenter.travel.aol.com/travel/lonely_planet/central_and_south_america/belize/culture.html

__________________
hotlink?

Date:
Permalink Closed

www.webcenter.travel.aol.com/travel/lonely_planet/central_and_south _america/belize/culture

__________________
hotlink?

Date:
Permalink Closed

Nope. Won't work. Maybe Googler or somebody can hotlink it.

__________________
hot link

Date:
Permalink Closed

Sorry.  It's dead.  Here's a link to the IDV site:


http://www.usm.edu/idv/pages/StudentTravel.html#abroad


You can link on the Belize "click here" in the center of the page, but all you get is a broken link.  I tried to open a cached version, but all I got was a "does not exist" response.



__________________
ToppleTheTop

Date:
Permalink Closed

Website sanitization started again the day they unlinked the IDV webpage from the USM main webpage a few weeks ago.

__________________
hot link

Date:
Permalink Closed

quote:

Originally posted by: Amy Young

"This is not good. I googled and found... If someone could make this a hotlink, you could read many of the words on the brochure. http://webcenter.travel.aol.com/travel/lonely_planet/central_and_south_america/belize/culture.html"


Try clicking above. Or here:


http://webcenter.travel.aol.com/travel/lonely_planet/central_and_south_america/belize/culture.html


Might get you to the Lonely Planet site.



__________________
Googler

Date:
Permalink Closed

quote:

Originally posted by: Amy Young

"This is not good. I googled and found... If someone could make this a hotlink, you could read many of the words on the brochure. http://webcenter.travel.aol.com/travel/lonely_planet/central_and_south_america/belize/culture.html"

So does the Belize brochure contain plagiarized content?

__________________
Amy Young

Date:
Permalink Closed

quote:

Originally posted by: Googler

"So does the Belize brochure contain plagiarized content? "


So it appears.


 



__________________
USM = sad, sad, sad

Date:
Permalink Closed

From the LONELY PLANET WEBSITE: (I bolded any words/changes in the original text from what appear in the brochure; otherwise assume it is verbatim plagarism).
Belize is officially English-speaking, but the creoles (the largest ethnic group) speak their own colorful dialect as well as standard English. Spanish is the main language in the north and some towns in the west. You may also hear Mayan, Chinese, Mennonite German, Lebanese, Arabic, Hindi and Garífuna (the language of the Garinagu people of Stann Creek district) being spoken.

The majority of Belize's population are Roman Catholics, but British influence has created a sizable and varied protestant congregation, including German Swiss Mennonites. The Mayan practice of Catholicism is a fascinating fusion of shamanist-animist and Christian ritual.

Belize has never really developed a national cuisine. Its cooking borrows elements from the UK, the USA, Mexico and the Caribbean. The traditional staples are rice and beans. These are often eaten with chicken, pork, beef, fish or vegetables. Coconut milk and fried plaintain add a tropical flavor.

From the IDV BROCHURE:
Belize is officially English-speaking, but the Creoles (the largest ethnic group) speak their own colorful dialect as well as English. Spanish is the main language in the north and some towns in the west. You may also hear Mayan, Chinese, Mennonite German, Lebanese, Arbic, Hindi and Garifuna being spoken.

The majority of Belize's population is Roman Catholics, but British influence has created a sizable and varied protestant congregation, including German Swiss Mennonites. The Mayan practice of Catholicism is a fascinating fusion of shamanist-animist and Christian ritual.

Belize has never really developed a national cuisine. Its cooking borrows elements from the UK, the USA, Mexico and the Caribbean. The traditional staples are rice and beans. These are often eaten with chicken, pork, beef, fish or vegetables. Coconut milk and fried plaintain add a tropical flavor.
*****

How sad is this? It's not the first time USM has plagarized--I seem to remember multiple occasions of this type of thing (remember when they literally copied the Auburn letter about SACS probation?). I wouldn't go to the administration first about this; someone should e-mail Lonely Planet. Their website is copyrighted PLUS Lonely Planet makes money off their tourism guide books. I hope they sue USM! Maybe IHL would finally wake up.

__________________
Googler

Date:
Permalink Closed

Excerpt from Interested Bystander's post on the "Mad as Hell on EagleTalk" thread:


"Edward Waters, a small school in Florida, had its SACS accreditation pulled at the same SACS meeting in December. They were cited for plagurizing their self study. BEWARE!!!"


Let's not dig the hole any deeper.


 http://www.plagiarism.org/



__________________
Plagiarism is theft!!

Date:
Permalink Closed

"Dr David Butler" has his name attached to the brochure. He is, therefore the plagiarist. Pathetic, pathetic, pathetic. You've got some college down there in Mississippi

__________________
Googler

Date:
Permalink Closed

quote:

Originally posted by: Plagiarism is theft!!

""Dr David Butler" has his name attached to the brochure. He is, therefore the plagiarist. Pathetic, pathetic, pathetic. You've got some college down there in Mississippi"

Don't make fun of our college. This brochure might be the dissertation of one of Dr. Butler's IDV students.

__________________
Amy Young

Date:
Permalink Closed

I hope this can be corrected ASAP because it is terribly embarrassing!  I emailed a dean and asked for his intervention.


Amy Young



__________________
Robert Campbell

Date:
Permalink Closed

Amy,

At the very least you'll learn whether an academic dean actually has any authority over the International Development program.

Robert Campbell

__________________
Abbot & Costello

Date:
Permalink Closed

quote:

Originally posted by: Amy Young

"I hope this can be corrected ASAP because it is terribly embarrassing!  I emailed a dean and asked for his intervention. Amy Young"

Amy, which of the many deans might that be? With the constant moving of programs from one college to another I can't tell whose on first.

__________________
Angeline

Date:
Permalink Closed

Whoever committed the plagiarism - be it Butler - or someone else working for their program (hell, they probably outsourced it and are getting what they paid for) should be at least professionally reprimanded and at best fired for academic dishonesty.  My G-d USM has become such a laughing stock.  Even my students who have plagiarized papers usually use at least a few websites rather than just one.  Unbelievable laziness.

__________________
standupguy

Date:
Permalink Closed

Dr. Butler's ethics are not fully developed.  Look into student complaints about the way he forces students to do his research.  He needs strong mentorship from senior faculty.

__________________
About to Get Flamed??

Date:
Permalink Closed

Besides the obvious plagiarism issue, which I agree should cost Butler at least an official reprimand, what exactly would one find offensive about the brochure (RE: its content)? The program looks very much like some of the other "Caribbean Studies" programs that are being run across campus: collect data, get a suntan, live fast & loose, and come back to the 'Burg with 6 hours credit.

__________________
Business One

Date:
Permalink Closed

Isn't Cont. Educ. mailing out about 17, 000 of these at the present time?

__________________
Amy Young

Date:
Permalink Closed

I am involved with the Caribbean studies program, and have been for a number of years. The students get FOUR credits and we stay longer. Also, the classes we offer at USM have gone through the process of academic council.

Dr.Tim Rehner is the director of that Jamaica program and has been watching SACS and making sure all of the classes are up to par, believe me!

__________________
astonished

Date:
Permalink Closed

Note that the IDV class is a 600 level class, requiring the collection of data and expected publications, without any prerequisites such as experimental design, statistics, research methods, all those things that would create a foundation for quality research.  There is, required interaction via email prior to the class - whoop de do!  Our undergraduates are required to have some foundation prior to participation in any level of research.  This is a waste of a graduates student's time, unless they understand full well that the only value is some exposure to another culture.

__________________
Emma

Date:
Permalink Closed

quote:

Originally posted by: Amy Young

"I hope this can be corrected ASAP because it is terribly embarrassing!  I emailed a dean and asked for his intervention. Amy Young"


And, Amy,


When Pood can quit hiding behind/under his desk as he quivers in fear, maybe he'll get back to you!!!!!!!!!



__________________
No No Nanette

Date:
Permalink Closed

quote:

Originally posted by: Robert Campbell

"Amy, At the very least you'll learn whether an academic dean actually has any authority over the International Development program. Robert Campbell"

Robert, it is my understanding that your question was answered today: NO!

__________________
Angeline

Date:
Permalink Closed

Hopefully Amy Young will update this thread, but my understanding is that the brochure has been scrapped and Butler has a red face.

__________________
Educational Dysfunction

Date:
Permalink Closed

Economic Development is the achilles heel...always has been.

__________________
1 2  >  Last»  | Page of 2  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard