Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: USM works on first honor code
Reporter

Date:
USM works on first honor code
Permalink Closed


USM works on first honor code

By David McRaney


November 22, 2005


http://www.studentprintz.com/vnews/display.v/ART/2005/11/22/438270182980e



__________________
disgusted student

Date:
Permalink Closed

now if we could just come up with an honor code for administration we would really be world class.

__________________
astonished

Date:
Permalink Closed

Let it be noted that the COB has had an official code of conduct for some time. Reference is made to it on all syllabi

__________________
Instant Grits

Date:
Permalink Closed

Reporter wrote:


USM works on first honor code

An honor code will not work at USM. Honor codes are built over time and are based on traditiion. Traditions are developed, not invented. An honor code is not like a box of instant grits. Students at schools with an honor code enforce those code with a passion.

__________________
Invictus

Date:
Permalink Closed


Instant Grits wrote:

An honor code will not work at USM. Honor codes are built over time and are based on traditiion. Traditions are developed, not invented. An honor code is not like a box of instant grits. Students at schools with an honor code enforce those code with a passion.


Nice try but no cigar. Honor codes are no more a matter of "insitutional tradition" than the content of a freshman biology syllabus. And students at schools with honor codes often abuse those codes, if they're given the chance. (Re: Cheating scandals at major universities, service academies, etc.)

I'm surprised USM doesn't have an institutional honor code. Of course, even 30+ years ago, I had profs who put their classes on the "honor system" & generally about half the students took that as carte blanche to cheat like hell.

__________________
Instant Grits

Date:
Permalink Closed

Invictus wrote:


Nice try but no cigar. Honor codes are no more a matter of "insitutional tradition" than the content of a freshman biology syllabus.

Sorry, Invictus, but I speak from experience. You'd have to be there to believe it. I've been there. You must be talking about an honor system in name only.

__________________
Outsider Wanting to Know

Date:
Permalink Closed

Is this an honor code in name only?  If not, how many students in the CoB courses have been disciplined for inappropriate behavior under this code?  From my sources inside the CoB no student has been disciplined under their honor system.  Can I draw the conclusion that business students do not cheat? 

__________________
Dewey, Cheatam, and Howe

Date:
Permalink Closed

Each college within the university developing its own honor code is not only stupid it is silly. Such a practice would surely confuse the non- majors taking their courses. An honors code should be consistent across the entire university. My guess is that business developed its own honor code for the sole purpose of partially satisfying some accreditation committee that says ethics must be incorporated into the business curriculum.

__________________
First Adopters

Date:
Permalink Closed

Either that or they were ahead of the curve and the university is just now catching up.

__________________
Kangaroo

Date:
Permalink Closed

Dewey, Cheatam, and Howe wrote:


Each college within the university developing its own honor code is not only stupid it is silly. Such a practice would surely confuse the non- majors taking their courses. An honors code should be consistent across the entire university. My guess is that business developed its own honor code for the sole purpose of partially satisfying some accreditation committee that says ethics must be incorporated into the business curriculum.

You got it, D, C, & H.  What happens if a student outside of business is suspected of cheating? Is a theatre major who takes a business course tried by COB's honor court? Can each college at USM set up its own unique system of justice? Shades of Aruba.

__________________
Warden

Date:
Permalink Closed

Their Academic Integrity Policy specifies a faculty responsibility of "Ensuring that examinations are properly proctored." Under a true honors policy it is not necessary for the instructor to be present during the examinations. This makes it sound as if  the faculty has the honor and the students have the system  The entire plan is on their website. It reads more like a system for keeping prison inmates under control than an honor system.

 



__________________
Honor Code Alum

Date:
Permalink Closed

Doesn't the CoB have an "Academic Integrity Policy" that is different from an "Honor Code"?  I went to a private liberal arts college with a true Honor Code.  It was, as one of the posters noted above, an integral part of the culture and history of the college I attended.  I can't imagine a real honor code being suddenly adopted at a state university like USM and having it be successful.  A tradition can't be created overnight.  In response to some of the cynics above who did not attend an institution with an honor code, students took it very seriously and there was also pride associated with being part of it and making it work.



__________________
Blurry Moment

Date:
Permalink Closed

Honor Code Alum wrote:


 A tradition can't be created overnight.


What do you mean, son?


We got Nitchampburg.


We got The Rock.


We create traditions as the need arises.


When they've outlived their usefulness we create another.


In order to maintain our wurl' class modern status we can't let our traditions get out of date.


 


 



__________________
Whistling in the wind

Date:
Permalink Closed

Warden wrote:


Their Academic Integrity Policy specifies a faculty responsibility of "Ensuring that examinations are properly proctored."

So the COB policy requires that its faculty ensures that examinations are properly proctored. How will they do that with their online MBA program without violating that part of their academic integrity policy? Maybe they'll hiire someody on site to sit beside the student's computer and watch over their shoulder. I'll bet that component of their "Academic Integrity" policy goes down the tubes pretty fast.

__________________
Invictus

Date:
Permalink Closed


Instant Grits wrote:

You must be talking about an honor system in name only.



Like the one at the United States Air Force Academy? Or the United States Naval Academy? Or West Point? Unless I'm mistaken (and I am not), those honor systems are backed by military "justice" & all have been rather famously abused.

The real question is whether an honor system is necessary at USM. Given what I've observed regarding grade inflation, I'd have to offer that a student with a normal number of brain cells ought not to have to cheat to make the President's List at USM.




__________________
Invictus

Date:
Permalink Closed


Whistling in the wind wrote:

So the COB policy requires that its faculty ensures that examinations are properly proctored. How will they do that with their online MBA program without violating that part of their academic integrity policy? Maybe they'll hiire someody on site to sit beside the student's computer and watch over their shoulder. I'll bet that component of their "Academic Integrity" policy goes down the tubes pretty fast.



The Mississippi Virtual Community College, favorite whipping boy of this board, now requires at least one proctored exam in every online course, regardless of the subject matter. In that system, a proctored exam must be taken under controlled conditions at an approved testing center. Each community college has at least one such center. Students who cannot travel to a Mississippi community college testing center may propose alternative testing sites, subject to approval by the instructor and his/her Distance Learning Coordinator. Locations that are generally okay include public libraries, universities, military base education offices & K-12 schools. The proctors receive specific instructions for monitoring the exams, which are password protected & may be set to prevent printing, local saving of copies, etc.

You'll need to find a better argument that this against the online MBA program.



__________________
Whistling in the wind

Date:
Permalink Closed


Invictus wrote:





The Mississippi Virtual Community College, favorite whipping boy of this board, now requires at least one proctored exam in every online course


One proctored exam per online course would be just fine if only one exam was administered per course.


You'll need to find a better argument that this against the online MBA program.


I wasn't presenting an argument against the online MBA program (that's already been done by numerous posters and far better than I could do it).  I was pointing out that an online program and the COB's Academic Integrity policy are not compatible.






__________________
Copy Cat

Date:
Permalink Closed

Blurry Moment wrote:


We got Nitchampburg. We got The Rock.   


Blurry Moment, your tongue-in-cheek post listing some USM instant traditions missed the "Eagle Walk" which was stolen from Ole Miss' walk through The Grove which has been around for many decades. The USM band "The Pride of Mississippi " was a take off on "The Pride of the South" of Ole Miss. Ditto the new usage of "Southern Miss." If USM folks dislike Ole Miss, they sure have a strange way of showing it. At this rate we'll be seeing "Colonel Eagle" at our football games pretty soon.

__________________
Breaking Wind

Date:
Permalink Closed

Whistling in the wind wrote:


Invictus wrote: The Mississippi Virtual Community College, favorite whipping boy of this board, now requires at least one proctored exam in every online course One proctored exam per online course would be just fine if only one exam was administered per course. You'll need to find a better argument that this against the online MBA program. I wasn't presenting an argument against the online MBA program (that's already been done by numerous posters and far better than I could do it).  I was pointing out that an online program and the COB's Academic Integrity policy are not compatible.

And I belive Invictus merely pointed out your ignorance.  Perhaps in the future you should education yourself prior to expressing opinions.  Given the nationwide proctoring networks that are available it is fairly easy to use proctored exams in distance education.  I believe that USM has a proctoring system in place.  Afterall, many online courses and programs have been offered here for years.  The CoB currently offers online courses that make use of proctored exams -- this is nothing new.  There is no incompatibility between online courses and the CoB acdemic integrity policy.   Perhaps you should talk with distance learning experts before you attempt to explain what will and will not work. 

__________________
Whistling in the wind

Date:
Permalink Closed

Breaking Wind wrote:


 Perhaps you should talk with distance learning experts before you attempt to explain what will and will not work. 

I prefer to talk with academic experts.

__________________
Breeze

Date:
Permalink Closed

Don't let Breaking Wind rattle you, Whistling in the Wind. Breaking Wind is just blowing smoke. Yes they do have the proctoring contacts Breaking Wind mentioned, but some courses are offered without proctored exams whatsoever. Many online courses at USM are offered with no proctored exams and no check on who is actually taking online tests.

__________________
Breaking Wind

Date:
Permalink Closed

Breeze wrote:


Don't let Breaking Wind rattle you, Whistling in the Wind. Breaking Wind is just blowing smoke. Yes they do have the proctoring contacts Breaking Wind mentioned, but some courses are offered without proctored exams whatsoever. Many online courses at USM are offered with no proctored exams and no check on who is actually taking online tests.


If what you are saying is true, then you have identified a problem with faculty members not meeting their academic responsibility -- they are not doing the job they are paid to do.  And these would be the same academic experts Whistling in the Wind listens to?  And these are also the same "professionals" who say we cannot constrain how they teach classes without violating academic freedom?  Seems to me like the "administrators" have developed a system to protect academic quality but that some faculty members refuse to do the extra work necessary for such protection.  What in interesting twist!


 



__________________
anon

Date:
Permalink Closed

Breaking Wind wrote:


Seems to me like the "administrators" have developed a system to protect academic quality

Seems to me that most "administrators" don't know diddly squat about academic quality in disciplines outside their own area of expertise.

__________________
Anonymous Giving

Date:
Permalink Closed

Wow, you're being generous.  Some might argue that you could have ended your post 11 words sooner!

__________________
anon

Date:
Permalink Closed

Anonymous Giving wrote:


Wow, you're being generous.  Some might argue that you could have ended your post 11 words sooner!



__________________
Dance Floor Fight

Date:
Permalink Closed

anon wrote:


 Seems to me that most "administrators" don't know diddly squat about academic quality in disciplines outside their own area of expertise.

This reminds me of the old Sun Records rockabilly hit that went "My girl is red hot, your girl ain't doodly squat."

__________________
astonished

Date:
Permalink Closed

Students HAVE been disciplined under the academic policies - get specific numbers and offenses from the associate dean. 


The COB developed this because it felt the need for one, and the university would not move toward a univ. wide code.


Any student taking any course in the COB is bound by this code, as are the faculty teaching these courses.


The university code does not supercede any existing code.


 



__________________
Trump Card

Date:
Permalink Closed

astonished wrote:


The university code does not supercede any existing code.  

A university code should supercede any existing college code if the standards of the university code exceed the existing local college code.

__________________
Blind Mouse

Date:
Permalink Closed

astonished wrote:


Students HAVE been disciplined under the academic policies

I read the 'acdemic integrity' policy on their website. I saw nothing about a specific discipline or punishment. Did I miss something?

__________________
Miriam Webster

Date:
Permalink Closed


Trump Card wrote:

astonished wrote:
The university code does not supercede any existing code.  
A university code should supercede any existing college code if the standards of the university code exceed the existing local college code.




Or superSede, in any case. From supersedere (Latin, "to sit on top").

__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard