Am I the only one, or did everyone missed Shelboo's sweetheart deal to clean out the Foundation and give University patents away? I was shocked to hear this from someone in the business community, but it seems that it happened late last year. Without any fanfare the Gnome gave a pile of Foundation cash and USM's patents to the Noetic Company. No wonder there is little money left in the Foundation, it is being pillaged as the Gnome is getting ready to close the door. Obviously a very suspect deal given his involvement in the company's ownership and the secrecy surrounding the action.
The complex financial wheelings and dealings that have obviously gone on in the last four years are beyond the expertise of the average faculty member (or at least this faculty member). Many of us have wondered about the murky relationships among these entities, and most of us have little confidence that good oversight and due diligence takes place in these behind the scene operations. My overall impression (and this is just an impression and not based on any hard evidence) is that a small number of folks will get very rich off these arrangements, and the benefits will be very limited for our students and most faculty and staff. If this was something worth braggin' on for the university in general, our PR folks would be making the case (more than just a paragraph on the website) loud and clear. If we get a President worth his or her salt come April, that person would be well served to set an independent team of forensic accountants loose on the books. It all may be perfectly legal and all good, but without a bit more public sunshine on these arrangements most of us will never know for sure. More scandal is something this university can ill afford.
Some have requested additional background information to consider with regards to the possibility of pillaging. This really could become a lasting legacy of Shelby’s nepotism extended to those who are in his family by education, the beneficiaries having earned their degrees from the little man. The obvious connections are:
Research Foundation – a Thames alumnus happens to be the President of its Board of Director, he is also on the State of Mississippi payroll in the Polymer Department and also just happens to be the co-founder of Shelboo’s bestest in the wurl Paint Company.
Noetic Technologies – founded by Alumni of Thames’ Polymer program and headed by a Thames alumnus. This once non-profit company with a university payroll is now in “private” hands.
Innovation and Commercialization Park – What some say is a boondoggle to be built out of the old university golf course. However, keep in mind, the planning just happens to be led by the aforementioned heads of Noetic and the USM Research Foundation, and the park just happens to be the recent recipient of more than $30 million in government pork monies.
Further scandal for Southern Miss maybe in the offiing as I understand that none should be surprised if the Park, with its millions, is turned over to “private” hands just before May 20th. A nice gift for an incoming President .
OM
(with thanks to Nowhere Man for filling in blanks and company name correction)
A donation of about $1 million as well as patented molecules and chemical processes from an undisclosed Fortune 500 company has resulted in a privately-owned company to help sell intellectual property and research created at the University of Southern Mississippi.
University and company officials on Thursday unveiled Noetic Technologies Inc., which will be a standalone company.
"What we do is go out and target companies that would use this technology that would need this technology and again we could either license it or license them the ability to make these molecules and sell them," said Les Goff, chief executive officer and president of Noetic.
Noetic, he said, is Greek for "of the intellect" and will be the only company of its kind at work with a university in the state....
...Part of the company is owned by the university's research foundation while Goff along with the two other employees - Kelli Booth and Vance Flosenzier - are owners who will earn a percentage of what they sell.
USM receives money on licensing through the research foundation....
...He said it typically takes a year to a year and a half to see results from marketing work....
-------------- HA, 6/28/04
Third parties assess value of research group
The $39 million value of the net assets held by the Research Foundation at the University of Southern Mississippi was calculated by third parties under strict guidelines, said Angie Dvorak, who will become foundation president Thursday.
Most of the foundation's assets are donated intellectual property packages, which one day may make the university money, but earn nothing now, she said.
"Intellectual property is worthless unless you do something with it," Dvorak said.
The foundation has about $1.2 million in cash, she said....
... "Then Angie came on board," Burge said. "The very first night she was here, a Fortune 500 company came to town. What impressed me is they donated three technology packages but she was able to talk them into a substantial cash donation."
Unlike a donation of intellectual property, a cash donation is spendable and some has been used to set up Noetics Technologies Inc. to turn the assets into profit for the university....
... Any money made by Noetics will go into the foundation but only after taxes are paid, she said....
... To date, all of the intellectual property donations have dealt with the polymer industry.
"We anticipate that could change very rapidly," Dvorak said, "now that we have a full time focus on it."...
-------------------
MS Business Journal, 12/13/04
Noetic Technologies moves research to commercialization
...Goff, whose wife is a polymer science professor at Southern Miss, said "there are many clever professors and scientists at Southern Miss who don't really have a good understanding of how to turn technology into commercial projects. They understand working with companies, but they don't understand those process steps. Shelby Thames is an entrepreneur and understands that process. We're a piece of his mission of taking technology and driving it to the marketplace."...
...Noetic Technologies already has several high- profile projects in its portfolio. Shell Chemical Company of Houston, Texas, donated intellectual property to the university's research foundation, which turned it over to the firm for commercialization....
....Even though other universities have licensing groups to handle intellectual property and file patents, Noetic Technologies also assists with business development, marketing, joint venture opportunities and "a whole myriad of opportunities that normally a licensing group in a university doesn't touch," said Goff, who pointed to economic development projects. "We're on the periphery of talking to companies about relocating"...
------------------------
A Work in Progress, 4/05
...A new company, Noetic Technologies Inc., was formed in 2004 to create opportunities for entrepreneurs at Southern Miss, becoming the commercialization and marketing arm of the university’s research foundation....
...Noetic Technologies Inc., a company created for entrepreneurs at Southern Miss, announced in 2004 its first business partnership with Biocare Medical of Walnut Creek, Calif....
...The University of Southern Mississippi Gulf Coast Research Laboratory and Noetic Technologies Inc. are collaborating to commercialize scientific advances in shrimp farming that have resulted from GCRL research and development. ...
----------------------
HA, 2/22/06
Work may begin at USM park within year
...The [Lake Sehoy] center will allow those entrepreneurs to take an experimental product they have worked up in a laboratory and determine the best way to mass produce it, Thames said.
Then groups like Noetic Technologies, an arm of Southern Miss' research foundation, can help a new business locate its clientele and market its product.
"We want it to be open to all researchers who want to take their ideas and dreams and see them in the market instead of sitting on a shelf somewhere," Noetic President Les Goff said.
"We'll even go with them to the bank and say this is what their chance of success is," Thames added.
The university could earn profits from the center by collecting a percentage of royalties of companies that use the research tools in developing their product for market, Thames said.
But the long-term goal is to attract major industries that will locate their own research division at the technology park and create jobs for the area....
------------------ HA, 9/12/06
Godwin appointed to SSTI board [USM PR in HA]
...She [Godwin/Dvorak] led the creation of Noetic Technologies Inc., the for-profit intellectual property development and management arm for the research foundation and university....
-----------------
HA, 12/4/06
USM's biotech stature growing
..."The growth in the biotech area has represented the largest part of our growth in research funding," which has soared from about $40 million annually to more than $100 million in the last year, said Ken Malone, chair of the department of economic and work force development.
Contributing to Southern Miss' efforts to bring research ideas to market is Noetic Technologies, the university's licensing and marketing arm that matches business people with researchers to launch commercial ventures, said Noetic President and Chief Executive Officer Les Goff.
Noetic now is actively promoting between 50 and 60 patents, he said.
"Our industry partners take technology that would normally sit on a shelf and really make it into something," Goff said. That way, the partnerships profit and royalties come back to the university and its research foundation. "Everyone has what I would call a little skin in the game," he said.
And licensing income can mean big money for universities battling budget woes.
While polymer science, biochemistry and marine science are Southern Miss' main opportunities for new patents, Goff said a bevy of other disciplines have much to offer as well.
A recent success came out of the forensic science department, when instructor Dean Bertram's partnership with researchers at Forrest General Hospital yielded a new way to enhance fingerprints taken from desiccated human tissue. The method was marketed as a kit after partners incorporated KDL Solutions, LLC - and it's been used by coroners after Hurricane Katrina and the U.S. Department of Defense in Iraq, Goff said.
Noetic also is marketing research from the mathematics, construction, computer science and disabilities studies fields, he said....
Mr. Lassen may have been in over his head from an academic standpoint but he was not a dishonest man nor was he a novice in financial matters. He got out (bless his heart) while the getting was good. I don't know Mr. Morgan but suspect that he also is not involved. Who then is behind any financial shenanigans? Shelby certainly doesn't have the background on his own...
"Scientific, business and news organizations from New York to Beijing are praising a promising recent discovery at the University of Southern Mississippi’s polymer science school. ... With National Science Foundation funding, Urban’s research team says it has found a way to modify the surface of medical devices to allow the antibiotic penicillin to coat them, killing bacteria that try to glom on."
For more on this story, see Monday's Hattiesburg American.
New company to find buyers for technology- he said....
info, thanks for the background. This could be a breaking story as unexpectedly, precise information is being offered off line. It appears there was a major change in Noetic Technologies late last year after it was apparent Shelby would go, somehow majority ownership transferred from the Research Foundation to the private individuals. This was then immediately followed by a no-bid, multi-year, multimillion dollar contract being issued by the University for services from Noetic Technologies. This is beyond slimy if in fact all true. If not outright illegal, it would early violate competitive bidding and sunshine regulations.
Polyonomous – I understand Lassen left due to ethical concerns and now Joe is not among the inner circle of Sycophants. This is something that can happen when one has a Shelby Alum reporting to a Shelby Alum reporting to the Shelby himself.
The Secretary of State's web site, http://www.sos.state.ms.us/, provides very limited corporate name and officer information for businesses in the state. Noetic's annual filings for 2005 (dated 5/3/05) and 2006 (dated 5/25/06):
For both years the "Registered Agent and Office" is listed as:
Hanbury John I 118 College Drive PO Box 5116 Hattiesburg MS 39406
For both years the president is listed as Leslie Goff, and the secretary and treasurer are listed as Angeline Dvorak.
It just looks like somebody failed to update the registered agent information with the Secretary of State's office. Note to whomever: you really need to get that taken care of. Your registered agent information has to be up to date. However, I am surprised that the registered agent for a university-owned company is not the University Counsel. Surely that would be in his purview.
__________________
Love your enemies. It makes them so damned mad. ~P.D. East
...On Thursday May 13, the Thames administration announced the formation of Noetic Technologies, a private company under exclusive contract to the university to market patented inventions developed at USM or given to it by corporate donors. The venture is described as the "marketing arm" of the USM Research Foundation, which in turn is controlled by Angie Dvorak.
The issues raised when universities get into the intellectual property business are serious and complex, and really need an extended discussion of their own. So do the conflicts of interest that arise when full-time, permanent employees of a university open profit-making businesses that market products related to their work for the university. But what makes Noetic Technologies stand out is that its principals are not researchers. All three are full-time administrators, hired since Thames took over.
Les Goff, the President and CEO of Noetic Technologies, is also the Director of Innovation and Business Ventures at USM, reporting to Vice President for Research Angie Dvorak; Goff's wife, Sarah Morgan, is an Assistant Professor of Polymer Science, also recently hired under the Thames regime. Kelli Booth, another principal in Noetic, is the Coordinator for Marketing Development in Polymer Science; her husband, Ken Malone, holds multiple offices under Thames, mostly prominently as "Chief Operating Officer" at the Gulf Park satellite campus and Chair of the Department of Economic Development. The third principal in Noetic is Vance Flosenzier, the recently hired Director of Process Technology in the Department of Economic Development; his wife Diana Flosenzier is a Grant Proposal Specialist in Polymer Science. Vance Flosenzier is also one of several administrators whose salary and source of funding Thames recently refused to disclose to the Faculty Senate....
This is the most disturbing post I have read since the days of Pileum (a major fraud that went unpunished!). If there is anyone at USM that wants to dig into this, please reread the post on Foundation Financial Results. It has a link that shows you how to get the annual IRS filing that should provide significant additional clues about the Foundation's misdeeds. The raise provided to Tim Ryan is making a lot more sense to me now. He is playing the game at the gnome's direction.
Curmudgeon wrote: Is Leslie Goff Ken Malone's spouse?
Not unless they have a blue state marriage. Les appears to be a "he".
Les Goff is Sarah Morgan's husband...she is a professor in the Polymer Science Dept (and also a USM Ph.D grad...how's that for nepotism!). Ken Malone's spouse is Kellie...oh, can't remember her last name right now (starts with a "B"). You can do a quick search of the message board and find it out, I believe.
So all off this smoke and federal pork and loss of a university golf course is for the personal enrichment of a handful of selected individuals? Why am I not surprised?